The Milburn Review aims to get every young person learning or earning. Here are the main proposals and what they mean for employers across our science industries.
Background
Alan Milburn’s final report on young people and work, ‘From a Welfare State to a Working State’, sets out a 10-year programme to tackle the number of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET).
Nearly 1 million young people aged 16 to 24, around one in 8, are NEET, and the rate has barely been below 10% in 25 years. The government has said it will respond before Christmas, with a White Paper in 2027.
What the review found
- The labour market has moved against young people with youth employment falling, even as overall employment grows. Focus has been on supply-side measures and ignored demand.
- The education system is not providing young people with the aptitudes as well as qualifications needed in a fast-changing labour market.
- The health system is currently about diagnosing and treating illnesses, rather than identifying risks and preventing problems from escalating to keep young people in education or employment.
- The wrong questions are asked in the welfare system: ‘what can’t you do?’ rather than ‘what could you do?’
- Responsibility is fragmented between institutions, programmes and tiers of government.
Headline targets
- New national ambition: every young person should be learning, earning or actively participating.
- By 2036 the UK should aim to reduce the NEET rate to around 5%.
- 25,000 pre-apprenticeship places created and a path towards 270,000 under-25 apprenticeship starts a year by 2036, alongside a major expansion in further education for 18 to 24 year-olds.
- Explicit targets for government procurement, with a mandatory social value criterion linked to youth employment for projects over £5m; for projects over £50m, and major defence, energy and infrastructure contracts, youth hiring commitments should be mandatory.
Strategic shifts
- Change the youth labour market. Employers create more first jobs, youth apprenticeships and work experience and in return the government will make it easier, cheaper and less risky for employers to hire young people (a new bargain between the State and employers).
- Change education expectations. Qualifications are central, but providers must also be judged on the successful transition into further learning and work. Technical education should be on an equal footing with academic education and lessons from low NEET countries must be central to the reforms.
- Replace the fragmented offer with a permanent Youth Opportunity Service in every place in England. Devolving powers to strategic authorities to take responsibility for 16-24 year old participation.
What it means for employers
- A new ‘Young People First’ approach to labour-market policy and practice.
- Through the new bargain employers will be asked to create more first jobs, youth apprenticeships and work experience for young people.
- Government should adopt five new objectives, including making it financially worthwhile to hire young people, giving employers one simple route into support and removing avoidable regulatory and practical barriers.
- No further increase in the costs of hiring young people (with a Youth Employment Cost Index published every two years) and continuing to direct the Low Pay Commission to judge the pace of minimum wage rises.
- When fiscal conditions allow, a five-year glide path to lower employer NI for 21-24 year-olds starting in retail and hospitality, by doubling the point at which NI is payable from £5k to £10k.
- Incentivise employers who take on young people: £3k for those who have been NEET for 6 months or more, plus an additional £2k for individuals facing greater barriers to participation and a further £2k for businesses with fewer than 50 employees.
- The apprenticeship hiring payment rises from £2k to £2.5k and is extended to levy payers, with a new £2k payment for training providers.
- The package would cost around £1.1bn a year and create an estimated 170,000 additional job and apprenticeship opportunities.
Education and skills
- A better balance is needed between academic foundations, technical and practical learning, enrichment, employer exposure and preparation for working life.
- Vocational GCSEs provide a good direction for change but will need resources, funding and collaboration.
- The introduction of a ‘ready-for-work standard’ to support accountability. This would sit alongside judgements of attainment for providers.
- Within further and higher education, financial incentives are being recommended for colleges to target 16-17 year-olds who are NEET or at risk. Government should also work with universities and colleges to increase Level 4 and 5 skills provision.
- The aim within apprenticeships should be to double the number of young people completing an apprenticeship over the next decade, and by 2036, 35% of each cohort should have started an apprenticeship by the age of 25 (with under-25 starts rising towards 270,000 a year), as well as the recommended 25,000 pre-apprenticeship places.
- Abolish the top slice taken by HM Treasury from the Growth and Skills Levy and focus on under-25s, reducing funding for those aged over 25 and change the structure of how the Growth and Skills Levy is managed,
Read the full report
You can read Alan Milburn’s full report here.
Get involved
Cogent Skills will be working with employers across our sectors to explore the details of the report and shape a collective response on the issues that matter most.
To find out more and get involved, contact [email protected].





